← All articles How to Evaluate Drainage Consultant Experience Knowledge Centre

How to Evaluate Drainage Consultant Experience

Table of Contents

Last Updated: 20 October 2026

Why Drainage Consultant Experience Matters

A drainage consultant is a civil engineering professional who designs surface water and foul drainage systems, prepares flood risk assessments, and secures the approvals your project needs before work can start. Choosing the wrong one costs you time, money and goodwill with your local authority.

Experience matters because drainage approval is not a box-ticking exercise. Each local planning authority and Lead Local Flood Authority applies its own reading of the rules. A consultant who has worked in your area knows what those teams expect to see.

There is a second reason. Drainage sits early in the programme. Get it wrong and every trade behind it waits. Get it right and the project moves.

Below, we show you exactly how to test a consultant's experience before you appoint them, using the questions, documents and checks that separate real expertise from a polished pitch.

Key Takeaway A consultant's years in business tell you very little. What matters is how many applications they have taken through approval, in what conditions, and with which authorities.

Drainage Consultant Questions to Ask

Ask direct questions and listen for specifics. Vague answers are your first signal.

A strong drainage consultant will answer these without hesitating:

  • How many planning applications have you submitted in the last two years?
  • Which local planning authorities have you worked with most often?
  • Have you dealt with a site that flooded during construction? What did you change?
  • Who prepares your flood risk assessments, and are they a qualified engineer?
  • What happens if the council comes back with conditions?
  • Can you show me a scheme similar in size and ground conditions to mine?
  • Who is my point of contact, and how quickly do you reply?

Push on any answer that stays general. "We've done lots of projects" is not an answer. "We've taken eleven schemes through your authority since 2024, including two on clay" is.

A homeowner and a drainage consultant sitting at a kitchen table, reviewing documents and pointing at a site plan, with a laptop open nearby
A homeowner and a drainage consultant sitting at a kitchen table, reviewing documents and pointing at a site plan, with a laptop open nearby

One question people rarely ask but should: who actually signs the design? Some firms sell work and subcontract the engineering. Ask for the name and qualification of the person responsible.

Pro Tip Ask the consultant to talk you through a scheme that went wrong. Anyone who claims a perfect record is either new or not being straight with you. How they describe fixing a problem tells you more than any brochure.

Checking Drainage Planning Approval Experience

Approval experience is the clearest evidence you can check. It is also the easiest to verify, because the record is public.

Most local planning authorities publish planning registers online. Search the consultant's company name and you will see applications they have been involved with. Look for:

  • Applications in your authority area, not just anywhere
  • Schemes of a similar type to yours
  • Decisions that were approved rather than withdrawn
  • Conditions attached, and whether they look routine

You can also ask the consultant for a short list of planning references you can look up yourself. A firm with genuine experience will hand these over without fuss.

Then check the flood risk side. For many sites, the Lead Local Flood Authority is a statutory consultee and will comment on surface water drainage. A consultant who understands what that team looks for will design to their expectations from the start, rather than reacting to comments later.

The government guidance on flood risk and coastal change sets out when a flood risk assessment is required and what it should cover. Read the relevant section before your first call. You will spot a bluffing consultant quickly.

Reviewing Drainage Consultant Project Examples

Project examples are where most evaluations go wrong. People look at glossy photos and stop there.

Do this instead. Ask for two or three written case studies and read them for the following:

Get in touch Today →

  • Site constraints. What was difficult about the ground, the levels or the access?
  • Authority involved. Which council or flood authority approved it?
  • Design solution. What system was chosen, and why that one?
  • Outcome. Was it approved first time, or after amendments?
  • Your role. Did the consultant design it, or just advise?

A useful case study names the problem and the fix. A weak one says "we provided a full drainage design service" and shows a picture of a field.

Ask for a project that resembles yours in one specific way. If your site is on clay, ask for a clay site. If you are extending a listed building, ask for that. Relevance beats volume every time.

Watch Out Beware the portfolio that is all commercial sheds and no domestic work. A consultant used to large industrial sites may not be set up for a small extension, and you will pay for their learning curve.

Using a Drainage Consultant Proposal Checklist

A proposal should tell you what you are buying, what it costs and what happens if things change. Score each one against this checklist before you compare prices.

  • Scope written in plain terms, listing each deliverable
  • Named engineer responsible for the design, with qualification
  • Clear list of what is excluded
  • Fixed fee or a stated basis for fees, with no hidden extras
  • Number of revision rounds included
  • Response times for council comments
  • Programme with dates for site visit, design and submission
  • Confirmation of who liaises with the council
  • Terms for handing over drawings if you leave
What to check Good sign Warning sign
Scope Itemised deliverables "Full drainage service"
Fees Fixed or clearly defined "From" pricing with caveats
Revisions Stated number included Silent on revisions
Programme Dated milestones "As soon as possible"
Handover Drawings released on request Ownership retained

Pricing for drainage design varies with site size, ground conditions and the level of assessment needed. Ask each firm for a written quote against the same scope, then compare like for like.

The Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors publishes guidance on appointing consultants and agreeing terms, which is worth reading before you sign anything.

Pro Tip Send every firm the same written scope before they quote. Otherwise you will be comparing three different jobs and the cheapest will look cheapest for the wrong reason.

Red Flags to Watch For

Some warning signs are obvious. Others only show up once you know what to look for.

Here is what makes one cautious when reviewing another firm's work:

  • No named engineer. If nobody will put their name to the design, walk away.
  • No local authority knowledge. A consultant who cannot name the flood authority for your area has not worked there.
  • Pressure to sign. Genuine firms will give you time to read the proposal.
  • Unwillingness to share references. Planning references are public. Refusing to share them is odd.
  • Promises of guaranteed approval. No one can guarantee a council decision. Anyone who does is overselling.
  • No mention of revisions. Council comments are normal. A proposal that ignores them will cost you later.
  • Scope creep in the small print. Check what triggers an extra fee before you sign.

That last one catches people out. A low headline fee with chargeable extras for every council response can end up costing more than a higher fixed price.

Watch Out Never appoint on price alone. The cheapest proposal often excludes the flood risk assessment, the revision rounds or the council liaison, and those are the parts that decide whether your application succeeds.

Conclusion

The hardest part of evaluating a drainage consultant is that every firm claims the same things. The way through is to stop listening to claims and start checking evidence: planning references, named engineers, relevant case studies and a proposal you can score line by line.

That is the approach we take at The Drainage Designers. We work nationwide on domestic and commercial drainage design, from site visits and flood risk assessments through to final approvals. We design to Local Authority and Lead Local Flood Authority requirements, and we set out scope, fees and programme in writing before you commit.

If you want a proposal you can hold against the checklist above, get in touch and we will send one.

Frequently Asked Questions

What qualifications should a drainage consultant have?

Look for a consultant who holds a recognised civil engineering or drainage design qualification, such as a degree in civil engineering or a professional accreditation from a body like CIWEM or ICE. They should also be familiar with the relevant British Standards, including BS EN 752 for drainage systems and the SuDS Manual (C753). Membership of a chartered institution shows a commitment to professional standards. Ask for evidence of continuing professional development and check that their insurance covers drainage design work. A consultant who can explain how they keep up to date with changing regulations is a good sign.

How do I check a drainage consultant's experience with planning approvals?

Ask the consultant to provide specific examples of projects they have taken through the planning process, including the local authority involved and the outcome. A reliable consultant will be able to describe how they addressed conditions from the Lead Local Flood Authority and any drainage-related planning conditions. Request references from previous clients, such as architects or developers, who can confirm the consultant's track record. You can also ask whether they have experience with your specific council, as requirements can vary. A consultant who is transparent about past challenges and how they resolved them is often more trustworthy than one who claims a perfect record.

What should a drainage consultant include in a proposal?

A thorough proposal should outline the scope of work, including site visits, survey requirements, and the specific deliverables such as drainage design drawings, calculations, and a flood risk assessment if needed. It should state the consultant's understanding of the project and any assumptions. The proposal must clearly list fees, payment terms, and what is excluded, so you can avoid surprise costs. It should also include a timeline with key milestones and identify who will be your main point of contact. Check that the proposal references the relevant planning policies and standards, and that it explains how the consultant will liaise with the local authority.

Should a drainage consultant visit the site?

Yes, a site visit is essential for an accurate drainage design. A consultant needs to see the existing drainage infrastructure, ground conditions, and site levels to assess constraints and opportunities. They should check for any nearby watercourses, sewers, or flood risk areas that could affect the design. A site visit also allows the consultant to identify potential issues that might not be obvious from desk study alone, such as access restrictions or existing services. If a consultant proposes a design without visiting, ask how they will verify the site conditions. A thorough site visit demonstrates diligence and reduces the risk of costly revisions later.